What happens if my tenant doesn't accept or sign the renewal?
A renewal isn't in force until everyone has signed it. Until then your current agreement carries on as normal, and you have a few options depending on how far along it is.
Signing hasn't finished
A renewal goes straight to signing when you send it. You sign first, then your tenant. It shows as Awaiting signatures on your Tenancy Agreement List with a Renewal badge, and your tenancy shows Renewal awaiting signing.
- If your tenant has gone quiet, a reminder from you usually does the trick. They sign from the link in their email from eSignatures, which arrives once you've signed.
- If your tenant wants a change to the terms, click Withdraw. Withdrawing sets the renewal to Pending Withdrawal and shortly after to Withdrawn. Then start a fresh renewal from the Renew button on your current agreement. Everything is pre-filled again, so it only takes a minute. See How do I change lease terms before the lease is finalised?.
Renewals sent before 2 November 2026 still need your tenant to accept first. While one shows as Sent, click Cancel to turn it back into a draft you can edit and send again.
The current lease ends before the renewal is finalised
Legally the tenancy rolls into a periodic one on the existing terms, and PropertyNow does the same automatically. When the fixed term ends with no signed renewal in place, the tenancy switches to periodic, rent keeps being collected on the same schedule and at the same amount, and you and your tenant each get an email confirming the change. If your tenant pays by PayTo they'll need to set up a new PayTo agreement, because the old one ends with the fixed term; their email tells them to do this. The renewal stays pending until everyone has signed, and then takes effect from the start date you chose. See What happens when a fixed-term lease ends without a renewal?.
If the renewal included a rent increase, the higher rent only applies from the new agreement's start date, so the sooner it's signed the sooner it kicks in.
Your tenant doesn't want to renew at all
If they decline, or tell you they're moving out, cancel or withdraw the renewal so it doesn't sit on your dashboard, then handle the end of the tenancy as usual. If you'd like help preparing notices for your state, get in touch.
For the renewal process from the start, see How do I renew a tenancy or update the agreement?.
Updated on: 02/11/2026
Thank you!
